I was reading a post by bnaz in which she said she wanted Robin to be Zelena’s villainous side kick. And the more I think upon this, the more I believe it to be true. HERE’S WHY:
In Season 3, there’s absolute confusion as to how the citizens returned to Storybrooke (who cast the curse). Zelena is a new face in town and I’m certain everyone heard about the new addition that was Snow’s new nanny. Zelena walked around town, ate at Granny’s, and made friends. Therefore, its safe to assume that H00d came into contact with her AT SOME POINT, even if in passing on Main Street. Now, here’s where I get suspicious.
While no one remembered the missing year, they remembered before that. And H00d encountered Zelena decades before, when stealing from her (Heart of Gold 4x18). And yes, Zelena had been green when he first met her but she would be recognizable with her red hair and sharp features. Why did he not speak up and say, “That’s the Wicked Witch! I encountered her years ago!”
He stayed quiet! Then he preceded to pretend not to know her when he had. Then, when he happened to be at Zelena’s SB home, without his men (random much), he shot at Regina even though you clearly see that he had time to tell the difference between Regina and Zelena (And look at his face actually. I detect a small smirk as he’s shooting– first gif)
He then says that he confused her with the Wicked Witch. Sorry, he had enough time to tell between two women that look nothing alike:
I call bullshit on that! But let’s move on, shall we!
He immediately makes a move on Regina when they enter the house, even blatantly showing off his tattoo (He made it certain that it would be visible to her by pulling up his sleeves)
Who the fuck hold a glass like that?! (AND LET’S REMEMBER CORA AND THE SHERIFF WITH TH FAKE TATTOO) Then she storms off and he pursues. Finally Regina kisses him and from there, it’s gotten so much weirder.
Zelena is killed (and let’s be real, he made no move to help defeat her) and Emma goes back in time, bringing “Marian” with her. Robin immediately joins his wife again, making Regina second choice. “Marian”, Robin, and Roland seemed like a happy family until “Marian” was hit with Elsa’s blast.
Did he not notice ANY changes in his wife? He knew her for so long, loved her for so long. I know people talk about his obliviousness in NY but my suspicions are more in SB. THEY SEEMED HAPPY.
Then they go off to NY and Robin chooses “Marian” AGAIN. Later he tells Regina that he feels idiotic for not knowing but it’s not idiocy, it’s impossible! We watched “Marian” and we knew she seemed strange. How could a man that KNEW her for decades not know? Especially when magic is a part of your world? Especially when YOU USED THAT NECKLACE YOURSELF TO HIDE FROM RUMPLE!!! HE HAD TO SEE IT (ESPECIALLY DURING SEX BECAUSE SHE HAD TO WEAR IT DURING THAT ACT)
Unless she didn’t have to hide it. Unless Robin knew who she really was and they were doing it (keeping the glamour) for Roland, to keep their secret.
He gets her pregnant and after learning that it wasn’t his Marian, he didn’t even move away from Zelena! When you’re lied to and deceived, even if she’s pregnant, you want distance.
Whatever, they go back to SB and shit happens. THEN WE HAVE THE AU.
Villains are supposed to be happy while hero are evil/miserable.
He doesn’t look miserable to me. In fact, he seemed totally in love with Zelena. This says to me that they’re both villains in the actual story so they got happy endings.
HE MARRIES HER FOR FUCKS SAKE!
Then a few days ago, a fan brought up that they thought he was shady. Adam’s response was just as shady IMO
I don’t know if the above is just ignorance by the writers but the evidence is adding up.
Let me tell you, this plot twist would be so well received and would fix A LOT for this show. It would erase the 0Q mess that is disliked by the GA, erase the rape (as it would’ve been consensual sex), and it would clear up so many plot holes. Yes, it would hurt Regina but in the end it would be the best for her, IMO. She deserves better. Emma is preferable but I’ll take anyone that ACTUALLY PUTS HER FIRST (I’d take a new male character at this point).
Also, in my mind, this plot twist would give this show some creditability again, maybe help gain viewers and ratings, and possibly save the show.
This is all speculation but I do think H00d is suspicious and that this is the best way to go.
Feel free to add suspicious H00d behavior if I missed any…
I also just remembered Regina’s dream (when she was undercover in Rumple’s cabin).
Regina later explained to Emma that she thought that in the dream, the Evil Queen was protecting Robin but what if she was PROTECTING REGINA FROM ROBIN. What if her subconscious has seen the signs we all see.
She’s says, “get away from ME!”
This to me, and anyone thinking clearly, shows that deep down Regina knows something is wrong with him and their relationship.
she says “get away from him,” doesn’t she? but she could still be protecting herself. if this is the “it’s all there” Adam ikeeps talking about, i might forgive him.
a little.
saypussy-again
All I’m getting out of Adam’s “it’s all there” is that RH is a shady mofo. To me, the signs are all there.
A lot of things would make sense really. Like when Zelena threatened Roland instead of Robin himself, they needed to make a scene and use a good reason for Robin to give up the heart so that when he told Regina about or she confronted him she would forgive him, b/c “nothing is worth the loss of a child”
I vote that when regina finds out emma is her true love/happy ending, she’s holding something belonging to emma and like in the first season finale, with emma holding the storybook, she suddenly has a vision of every single moment she has shared with emma and everything adds up and then she opens her eyes and emma is standing in front of her like
holtzmannsdimple
